Synthetic vs Conventional Oil: What's Best for Your Car?

Written by FixterPublished: 8th January, 2025

Choosing the right type of oil for your car can be a daunting task, especially with the myriad of options available today. One of the key decisions is whether to opt for synthetic or conventional oil. Each type has its own set of benefits and drawbacks, which can impact the performance and longevity of your vehicle. This guide aims to provide a clear and straightforward comparison between synthetic and conventional oils, helping you make an informed decision about what's best for your car. Whether you have synthetic oil change you're a seasoned driver or new to car maintenance, understanding the differences will ensure your engine runs smoothly and efficiently.

Logo
Need further assistance?
See our services
Lines

Understanding Engine Oil Basics

What is Engine Oil?

Engine oil is a crucial fluid for any vehicle, serving multiple purposes that keep your car running smoothly. It primarily acts as a lubricant, reducing friction between the moving parts of the engine, which helps in preventing wear and tear. Moreover, engine oil plays a vital role in cooling, as it helps dissipate the heat generated by the engine's operation. It also assists in cleaning, as it carries away contaminants and deposits that can accumulate over time. By forming a protective layer, engine oil ensures that the metal surfaces within the engine do not come into direct contact with each other. This, in turn, protects the engine from damage and extends its lifespan. Choosing the right engine oil, whether synthetic or conventional, is essential for maintaining optimal vehicle performance and reliability. Understanding these roles of base oils can help you appreciate why selecting the appropriate type of oil is so important.

Role of Engine Oil in Cars

Engine oil is indispensable for the efficient functioning of a car's engine. Its primary role is to lubricate the engine's moving parts, thereby minimising friction and reducing wear. This lubrication is crucial for maintaining the engine's performance and extending its lifespan. In addition to lubrication, engine oil helps in regulating the engine's temperature. By absorbing and redistributing heat, it prevents the engine from overheating, which can lead to severe damage. Engine oil also acts as a cleaning agent synthetic engine oil. It traps dirt, debris, and other contaminants, preventing them from causing harm to the engine. By keeping these particles suspended, the oil ensures they are removed when the oil is changed. Lastly, engine oil forms a protective coating on engine parts, safeguarding them against corrosion and rust. Together, these functions highlight the significance of choosing the right engine oil to maintain your car's performance and longevity.

Types of Engine Oils

Engine oils can be broadly categorised into three types: conventional, synthetic, and semi-synthetic. Conventional motor oil is derived from refined crude oil and is the most traditional type. It's generally less expensive and suitable for older vehicles with simpler engine designs. However, it may not offer the same level of protection under extreme conditions as other types. Synthetic oil, on the other hand, is chemically engineered to provide superior performance. It offers better lubrication, temperature stability, and engine protection, making it ideal for modern, high-performance cars. Semi-synthetic oil, or synthetic blend, combines elements of both conventional and synthetic oils, offering a middle ground in terms of performance and cost. It provides better protection than conventional oil, particularly in harsher driving conditions. Understanding these types helps you choose the right oil for your vehicle, ensuring optimal engine health and efficiency.

Synthetic Oil: Pros and Cons

Benefits of Synthetic Oil

Synthetic oil offers numerous advantages over conventional motor oil that make it a preferred choice for many vehicle owners. One of its primary benefits is superior lubrication, which provides excellent protection against engine wear. This is particularly important in high-performance engines where components operate under intense pressure. Additionally, synthetic oil has a higher resistance to oxidation and thermal breakdown, meaning it maintains its protective properties over a wider range of temperatures. This makes it ideal for extreme weather conditions, whether hot or cold. Synthetic oil also tends to stay cleaner for longer, requiring less frequent changes, which can be more convenient and cost-effective in the long run. Furthermore, its enhanced fluidity reduces friction, which can improve fuel efficiency. Although synthetic oil is generally more expensive than conventional oil, its benefits in terms of engine protection and longevity often justify the extra cost for those looking to maximise their vehicle's performance.

Drawbacks of Synthetic Oil

While synthetic oil boasts many advantages, it is not without its drawbacks. The most notable downside is its cost. Synthetic oil is significantly more expensive than conventional oil, which can be a deterrent for budget-conscious consumers. This higher price point can be attributed to the advanced engineering processes involved in its production. Moreover, despite its long-lasting and robust performance, synthetic oil might not always be necessary for every vehicle. Older cars or those with high mileage that have been running on conventional oil might not gain substantial benefits from switching to synthetic. In some cases, using synthetic oil in older engines can lead to oil leaks due to its thinner consistency. Additionally, synthetic oil can sometimes be overkill for vehicles that are not subject to extreme conditions or high-performance demands. Therefore, it's essential for car owners to assess their specific needs and vehicle requirements before making the switch from conventional motor to synthetic oil.

When to Choose Synthetic

Opting for synthetic oil is often advantageous under certain conditions. If you drive a high-performance vehicle or one that requires maximum efficiency, synthetic oil is generally recommended. Its superior engine protection and performance benefits make it well-suited for such demands. Furthermore, if you frequently drive in extreme temperatures, whether hot or cold, synthetic oil can offer more reliable protection against thermal breakdown and maintain optimal viscosity. It's also a wise choice for vehicles that undergo heavy towing or carry substantial loads, as the enhanced lubrication can better handle the increased strain. Synthetic oil is beneficial for engines that are exposed to frequent stop-and-go traffic, as it reduces wear during cold starts and short trips. If you're looking to extend the intervals between oil changes for convenience or cost reasons, synthetic oil's long-lasting properties are ideal. Ultimately, the decision to choose synthetic oil should align with your vehicle's specific needs, fuel economy, and your driving conditions.

Logo
Need further assistance?
See our services
Lines
Fixter logoWhy should I choose Fixter?
Synthetic vs Conventional Oil: What's Best for Your Car?

Conventional Oil Insights

Advantages of Conventional Oil

Conventional oil, often referred to as mineral oil, offers several advantages, particularly for budget-conscious car owners. The most apparent benefit is its cost-effectiveness. Being significantly cheaper than synthetic options, conventional oil is an economical choice for routine maintenance, especially for older vehicles with simpler engine designs. This type of oil is widely available, making it easy to find and replace during oil changes. Additionally, vehicles with high mileage that have traditionally used conventional oil may continue to perform well through longer oil change intervals without the need for switching to synthetic. Conventional oil is also suitable for cars that operate in mild driving conditions, where extreme temperatures and performance demands are not a factor. For those who adhere to regular maintenance schedules, conventional oil provides adequate protection and performance. While it may require more frequent changes compared to synthetic, its affordability and accessibility make it a viable option for many drivers seeking reliability without breaking the bank.

Limitations of Conventional Oil

Despite its affordability, conventional oil comes with several limitations that might influence your decision. One of the primary downsides is its tendency to break down more quickly than synthetic oil. This means that it requires more frequent oil changes to maintain engine protection and performance, which can add up in terms of time and cost over the long run. Conventional oil is also less effective in extreme temperatures. In very cold conditions, it might thicken, making it harder for the engine to start. Conversely, in high heat, it may thin out, offering less protection against friction and wear. Additionally, conventional oil lacks the advanced additives found in most synthetic oils varieties, which help prevent deposits and sludge build-up in the engine. This can lead to reduced efficiency and potentially shorten the engine's lifespan. For modern, high-performance vehicles, conventional oil might not provide the necessary lubrication and protection, making it less suitable for such applications.

Ideal Situations for Conventional Oil

Conventional oil remains a practical choice under certain conditions. It is particularly suitable for older vehicles that have consistently used this type of oil, as these engines might not benefit significantly from the switch to full synthetic motor oil options. For cars that are driven infrequently or primarily for short distances, conventional oil offers adequate protection without the need for the high-performance attributes of synthetic oil. In regions with mild climates, where temperatures don’t fluctuate dramatically, conventional oil can provide reliable performance without the risk of breakdown due to extreme weather. Additionally, for drivers who are diligent with regular maintenance and adhere to suggested oil change intervals, conventional oil can be a cost-effective solution. It's also a good choice for drivers of vehicles with simple engine designs that do not place high demands on the oil. Ultimately, conventional oil serves well in situations where budget constraints and moderate driving conditions align with its capabilities.

Comparing Synthetic and Conventional

Performance Differences

When comparing the performance of synthetic and conventional oils, several key differences emerge. Synthetic oil is engineered to provide superior lubrication, making it more effective at reducing friction and wear on engine components. This results in better protection, particularly at high temperatures and under heavy loads, where conventional oil might struggle. Synthetic oil also maintains its viscosity more consistently across a broad range of temperatures, enhancing engine performance in both cold and hot conditions. In contrast, conventional oil can thicken in cold weather or low temperatures, making engine starts more challenging, or thin out in high heat, offering less protection. In terms of longevity, synthetic oil outlasts conventional oil, reducing the frequency of oil changes and maintenance. This can lead to cost savings over time, despite the higher initial price of synthetic oil. Ultimately, while conventional oil is sufficient for many vehicles and driving conditions, synthetic oil offers a performance edge that is particularly beneficial for high-performance or modern engines.

Cost Considerations

Cost is a significant factor when deciding between a synthetic motor oil and conventional oil. Conventional oil is generally cheaper upfront, making it an attractive option for those on a tight budget or with older vehicles that don't require advanced lubrication. However, the lower price comes at the expense of more frequent oil changes, which can add up over time and potentially offset initial savings. Synthetic oil, while more expensive per litre, often extends the interval between oil changes due to its durability and superior performance. This can lead to fewer maintenance visits and less downtime for your vehicle. Additionally, the enhanced protection offered by synthetic oil can contribute to lower long-term engine wear, potentially reducing costly repairs. When assessing the cost, it's important to consider both the immediate expense and the long-term benefits associated with engine health and maintenance frequency. Each option has its place, and the best choice depends on your specific driving habits and vehicle requirements.

Impact on Engine Longevity

The type of oil you choose can significantly influence your engine's longevity. Synthetic oil is renowned for its ability to provide superior protection against wear and tear. It’s chemically engineered to maintain stable viscosity across a range of temperatures, reducing friction and enhancing engine efficiency. This can result in less stress on the engine's components, potentially extending its lifespan. Furthermore, synthetic oil's resistance to oxidation and thermal breakdown means it remains effective for longer periods, helping to prevent sludge and deposit formation, which can damage an engine over time. On the other hand, conventional oil, while adequate for many vehicles, does not offer the engine life same level of protection under extreme conditions. It may lead to increased wear if oil changes are neglected or delayed. Therefore, while conventional oil is suitable for older or less demanding engines, synthetic oil is generally better for those seeking to maximise engine longevity and performance.

Making the Right Choice

Assessing Your Driving Habits

When deciding between synthetic and conventional oil, it's crucial to evaluate your driving habits. Frequent short trips, lots of idling, or stop-and-go traffic can put extra strain on your engine, making synthetic oil a better choice due to its superior protection and efficiency. If you often drive in extreme weather conditions, whether sweltering heat or freezing cold, synthetic oil’s ability to maintain optimal viscosity can offer enhanced engine protection. Conversely, if you have a more relaxed driving style, covering longer distances at consistent speeds in mild climates, conventional oil might suffice. Additionally, consider how often you perform maintenance. If you prefer fewer oil changes, the extended intervals provided by synthetic oil might appeal to you should you use synthetic or conventional oil in your car. Ultimately, your driving environment and habits are key in determining which type of oil will best support your vehicle, ensuring it runs smoothly and efficiently over time.

Understanding Manufacturer Recommendations

Understanding manufacturer recommendations proper lubrication is pivotal when choosing between synthetic and conventional oil. Car manufacturers provide specific guidelines for oil type and viscosity to ensure optimal performance and engine longevity. These recommendations are based on extensive testing and are tailored to the specific engineering of your vehicle's engine. Ignoring these guidelines can lead to suboptimal lubrication, increased engine wear, and potentially void warranty coverage. For newer vehicles, manufacturers often recommend synthetic oil due to its advanced performance characteristics. However, older models or those with high mileage might be suited to conventional oil unless otherwise specified. It's also important to consider any updates or service bulletins from the manufacturer, as they may adjust their recommendations based on new findings or technology developments. Always refer to your vehicle's owner’s manual and consult with a trusted mechanic if in doubt. Adhering to these recommendations ensures your car operates efficiently and helps prevent unnecessary engine issues.

Balancing Performance and Budget

Finding the right balance between performance and budget is crucial when selecting engine oil. Synthetic oil, while more expensive, offers superior engine protection, fuel efficiency, and longer intervals between oil changes. These benefits can justify the higher initial cost, especially if you drive a high-performance vehicle or operate in extreme conditions. However, if cost is a primary concern and your driving conditions are less demanding, conventional oil provides a more budget-friendly option. It meets the basic lubrication needs for many vehicles and is suitable for drivers who adhere to regular maintenance schedules. Alternatively, semi-synthetic oils present a compromise, offering some of the benefits of full synthetic oils at a lower price point. Ultimately, your oil filter choice should align with both your financial situation and your vehicle's needs. Weighing the immediate costs against potential long-term savings and performance benefits will help you make an informed decision that suits both your budget and driving requirements.

Logo
Need further assistance?
See our services
Lines
Fixter
WHY FIXTER?

Simply book online and we'll handle the rest

Our in-house experts make sure any quotes you receive are relevant and fairly priced, so no nasty surprises!

We negotiate competitive rates with garages to offer the best prices, on average 30% cheaper than main dealerships.

We personally select and vet only the best local garages, fully covered by a 12-month warranty on parts and labour.

Our fully insured Fixter Heroes offer a contact free collection and delivery service, with flexible time slots that suit you.

yellow-car

How it works

Car maintenance, made easy in 4 steps

Our reviews